Refrigerator Repairs vs Replacement: How Much Should You Really Spend Before Buying a New One?

Refrigerator Repairs vs Replacement: How Much Should You Really Spend Before Buying a New One?

Written for PRS Parts Inc.

When your refrigerator starts making strange noises or stops cooling properly, you’re faced with a major decision: repair or replace? At PRS Parts Inc., we often get this question from customers across Hawai‘i who want to keep their appliances running—but also don’t want to throw money at something that’s on its last legs. Here’s a breakdown of when it’s worth investing in repairs, and when it’s time to consider buying a new fridge.

✅ Pros of Repairing Your Refrigerator

✔ Cheaper in the Short-Term

Most common refrigerator issues—like a broken thermostat, faulty defrost timer, or clogged drain—can be fixed for far less than the cost of a new unit. Repairs often range between $100–$400, depending on the part and labor.

✔ Keeps a Familiar Appliance

If you already love your fridge’s layout, features, and size, repairing it might be a better solution than finding a similar replacement.

✔ Reduces Waste

Keeping an appliance running longer helps reduce e-waste and is the more eco-friendly choice, especially if the repair is minor.

✔ OEM Parts Available

With OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts available at PRS Parts Inc., you can restore your fridge to factory-level performance with confidence.

❌ Cons of Repairing Your Refrigerator

✘ Cost May Exceed Value

If repair costs exceed 50% of the fridge’s current value, it's usually not worth it—especially for older units.

✘ Age Matters

Most refrigerators last 10–15 years. If yours is approaching or beyond this age, even a small repair may not prevent future issues. One fix now could lead to another problem in six months.

✘ New Units Are More Energy Efficient

Older models typically consume more electricity. Replacing a fridge that’s over 10 years old could cut your energy use by up to 20–30%, especially if you upgrade to an ENERGY STAR® certified unit.

✘ Availability of Replacement Parts

Certain brands or discontinued models may have limited part availability, leading to longer wait times or higher costs.

So… What’s the Magic Number?

Here’s a general rule of thumb:

  • If your fridge is under 8 years old and the repair is under $500, it’s likely worth fixing.

  • If it's over 10 years old and the repair estimate is more than 50% of the cost of a new model, you’re probably better off replacing it.

💡 Bonus Tip from PRS Parts Inc.

Before making a decision, let one of our team members help you diagnose the issue. Often, what seems like a serious problem can be resolved with a simple OEM part like a temperature sensor, relay, or water valve. We carry parts for Whirlpool, Samsung, GE, Frigidaire, LG, and more.

Final Thoughts

Making the right call between repairing and replacing comes down to age, cost, efficiency, and personal preference. At PRS Parts Inc., we’ll always give you an honest assessment and help you stretch your appliance’s life when it makes sense.

Visit PRS Parts Inc. at 540 Lagoon Dr. for OEM refrigerator parts, expert guidance, and service with the spirit of aloha

Back to blog